Fauci Diaries Reveal Lower Private COVID Death Estimate Than He Gave Congress

Newly released entries also show the former health official closely tracking his growing fame as the pandemic intensified

by Emmitt Barry, Worthy News Washington D.C. Bureau Chief

WASHINGTON, D.C. (Worthy News) – Newly released diary entries from Dr. Anthony Fauci show that he privately estimated COVID-19’s case fatality rate at between 0.2% and 0.3% in February 2020—roughly one month before telling Congress that the disease’s mortality rate would likely be about 1%.

The apparent gap between Fauci’s private assessment and his public testimony is drawing fresh scrutiny as the longtime federal health official prepares to appear before the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee. The diaries were released by the committee’s chairman, Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., a persistent critic of Fauci’s handling of the pandemic.

In a Feb. 8, 2020, entry, Fauci described a telephone conversation with former Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Director Dr. Tom Frieden. Fauci wrote that the two men believed the known number of infections represented only a fraction of the true total, meaning the fatality rate was likely substantially lower than the figures then being reported.

“He and I are on the same page in thinking that this is acting like a bad influenza in its transmissibility,” Fauci wrote, adding that the much larger number of undetected infections would make the case fatality rate “more like 0.2-0.3% rather than 2.0%.” Fauci’s notes listed 34,687 cases and 724 deaths at the time.

A Different Estimate Before Congress

On March 11, 2020, Fauci testified before the House Oversight Committee and presented lawmakers with a markedly higher assessment.

“The stated mortality overall of this, when you look at all the data including China, is about 3%,” Fauci told the committee. He acknowledged that the official figure would fall once minimally symptomatic and asymptomatic infections were included, but said it would probably decline only to “somewhere around 1%.”

That projected 1% mortality rate was still more than three times Fauci’s private estimate of 0.2% to 0.3%.

Fauci then told lawmakers that a 1% fatality rate would make COVID-19 “10 times more lethal than the seasonal flu,” offering the comparison as a way for the public to understand the threat.

The figures were not necessarily measuring precisely the same thing. A case fatality rate measures deaths among identified cases, while an infection fatality rate attempts to account for infections that were never diagnosed. Early pandemic estimates were highly uncertain because testing was limited and researchers did not yet know how many mild or asymptomatic infections had occurred.

However, Fauci’s February diary entry specifically reasoned that the large number of unidentified infections pushed the fatality rate down to between 0.2% and 0.3%. Critics are therefore asking why he did not present that private estimate—or clearly disclose the full range of his thinking—when testifying before Congress several weeks later.

Fame Amid a National Crisis

The newly released journals have also attracted attention because of Fauci’s repeated observations about his rising celebrity while COVID-19 deaths mounted across the United States.

“Press still hot and heavy about me,” Fauci wrote on April 7, 2020, noting that multiple stories involving him were appearing each day. By May 21, he described his national and international fame as “explosive and really unimaginable” and wrote that it was not an exaggeration to call himself one of the world’s most recognizable people.

Fauci also recorded media profiles, celebrity contacts and an invitation to appear on the television competition “Dancing with the Stars.” His diary included screenshots of favorable headlines and detailed his concern that his prominence might overshadow President Donald Trump.

Supporters of Fauci may argue that private diary entries naturally record unusual personal experiences and that scientific assessments changed rapidly as more information became available. The month between the February entry and March testimony brought new data, additional outbreaks and rising international alarm.

Critics, however, say the diaries reveal that Fauci privately entertained a far less alarming fatality estimate than the one he presented to lawmakers and the American public. They contend that Congress deserves a clear explanation of what evidence caused his estimate to rise—or why his lower private calculation was not disclosed during his testimony.

Fauci led the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases from 1984 until his retirement in 2022. Fox News reported that it sought comment from Fauci through Georgetown University, where he serves as a distinguished professor, but had not received a response at the time of publication.

His upcoming Senate testimony is expected to examine the diaries, the federal government’s early pandemic response, COVID-19’s origins and whether Fauci’s private communications were consistent with his public statements.

Lift this up in Prayer

14

people are currently praying.

Latest Worthy News